Welcome to the Moline Machinery v. City of Duluth Class Action Website.

A class action lawsuit was filed on behalf of Moline Machinery LLC, and Glass Merchant, Inc., d/b/a Walsh Windows (“Plaintiffs”) against City of Duluth (“Defendant”) in the case entitled Moline Machinery, LLC et al. v. City of Duluth, Case No. 69DU-CV-21-1668 (6th Jud. Dist. Cnty. of St. Louis, Minn.). Plaintiffs and the class are represented by Larson · King LLP and Trial Group North PLLP. The City of Duluth is represented by Greene Espel PLLP.

Your legal rights are affected whether you act or don’t act. Read this website and the Notice carefully.

The lawsuit addresses whether the City of Duluth failed to follow Minnesota law and its own City Code to properly calculate fees charged for stormwater service to owners of nonresidential properties. Plaintiffs allege the City of Duluth failed to charge or undercharged the required fees to certain nonresidential properties as required by City Code. Plaintiffs also allege the City of Duluth has unjustly and unfairly forced other owners of nonresidential property to pay the fees that should have been charged to the underpaying properties.

The Notice is being provided in advance of a trial. No judge or jury has concluded the Plaintiffs’ legal claims are correct or that the City of Duluth did anything wrong. For this reason, there is no money available now, and there is no guarantee there ever will be. If you are a class member, however, you have a choice to make now.


Your Legal Rights and Options in This Lawsuit
Exclude Yourself

Get out of this lawsuit. Get no money or benefits if any are available in the future. Keep the right to sue separately.

You have the right to exclude yourself from this lawsuit. If you timely submit an exclusion request, postmarked by March 18, 2024, the Court will exclude you from the lawsuit. If you ask to be excluded from the lawsuit and money or benefits are later awarded, you will not receive any money or benefits. You will keep any right to file your own lawsuit or be part of any other lawsuit against the Defendant.

Do Nothing

Stay in this lawsuit. Give up the right to sue separately.

If you do nothing, you may become entitled to money or benefits if later awarded, if Plaintiffs prevail at a trial or as part of a settlement. You will give up your rights to sue the Defendant. You will be bound by any future judgment regarding the Defendant.